Question Time: a petition for change

tony-gillardWe should adopt a policy advocating reform of Question Time.

It does not serve its purpose. It does not set an example for public debate. It should be completely re-thought.

I spent a number of days in the Federal Parliament this year and it’s not pretty. What you miss on TV but understand watching the whole chamber is the animalistic nature of it.

Two packs of animals. Someone runs up to the other pack, bares their teeth, then scurries back to their pack. It is a contest of intimidation. When a weakness is detected in a pack, the voices of the opposing pack rise up in catcall and ridicule. They sniff blood; the volume of animal noises increases. It is what I imagine a stoning is like.

Almost every question from the opposition attempts to embarrass the government, not solicit information. The repetition is sickening. Questions are repeated with minor variations so as to find a weak spot and dictate the news cycle.

Questions are almost all about the past. The questioners want to find an inconsistency, a failure, a lie. They want to attack. They want the media to righteously demolish their enemy.

Almost every answer blunts the attack by speaking for as long and indirectly as possible. When the government asks a question of itself it is designed to use up time and talk positively about accomplishments. Or about the failings of the opposition in previous years. Answers are press releases. How many thousands of bureaucratic hours are wasted in this?

I watched David Cameron in the House of Commons the day he answered 138 questions from the Opposition about phone hacking. Short, direct answers. The British Parliament is not perfect; it is adversarial and backwards-looking like ours, but there is respect and debate that is a level above what happens in Australia. Find me a politician that says different.

All of Australia talks about the brattish, churlish, unproductive, attention-seeking nature of Question Time. We should petition the Parliament for change.

Photo sourced from MystifyMe Concert Photography (Troy).

Sex Party's Fiona Patten wants to make Melbourne the new Milan

Fiona Eddie-Jim

Fiona Patten wants Melbourne to rival Paris or Milan as a fashion destination. Photo: Eddie Jim
Article by Jason Dowling

Melbourne should become an international fashion capital rivalling Paris and Milan and a new Victorian ministry for fashion should be created in the state government, according to a new MP.

Read more

POLICE GO OVERBOARD ON PERSONAL DATA ACCESS

Dataprivacy

FIONA PATTEN MLC

Fiona Patten, newly elected MLC for Northern Metro, has today expressed serious concerns around the overuse of authorisations by Victorian Police to obtain people’s phone and internet data.

“The revelation that Victoria Police are seeking access to citizen’s personal electronic data at least 1200 times per week is shocking,” said Ms Patten. “Law enforcement access to personal data should be subject to strict judicial oversight not at the whim of any officer as seems to be the case throughout the state.”

Read more

Instagram